Top Posts
German court dismisses climate case against RWE
WHO Climate Change action plan approved
Report: World likely to breach 1.5°C limit in...
At Bonn climate talks, Brazil demands early deals...
Researchers warn Africa could face 113 million climate...
LAPO MfB launches tree-planting initiative to fight climate...
Stiell says new NDCs are about growth, antidote...
EU trains 5,000 Imo farmers to combat climate...
Jigawa holds first summit on agriculture, climate change
NEST, experts demand subnational action to address climate...
EcoNai Newsroom
  • Newsround
  • Nigeria
  • Africa
  • World
World

Questions raised over validity of charges against climate protesters

by admineconai October 23, 2023
written by admineconai October 23, 2023
592

The validity of charges against 14 Queensland activists who are currently facing the possibility of jail, following a climate protest inside the state parliament has been questioned in court.

This is even as the case has been adjourned on Monday.

The group face charges – not laid in more than 30 years – of disturbing the legislature during a protest in which they unfurled banners with anti-fossil fuel slogans from the public gallery and interrupted question time by chanting for about three minutes last November.

Although the charges fall under section 56 of Queensland’s criminal code, which sets a three-year maximum jail term, a Brisbane court heard on Monday that a later section of the same act repeals section 56 as an offence.

Section 717 of the criminal code explicitly says that a person cannot be charged with, prosecuted, convicted or punished for disturbing the legislature. The police prosecutor, Martin Payne lodged a lengthy written submission over which section of Queensland’s laws was in effect at the time of the protest in parliament after amendments to the legislation in 2012.

Andrew Hoare, who is the barrister for the defendants was quoted as saying that there was “no ambiguity” over which section of the law was involved but had not had a chance to submit his own written submission. The magistrate Joseph Pinder gave Hoare five days to do so.

In a separate complication, Pinder was quoted as telling defence and prosecutors that he would not consider proceedings against all 14 defendants at once. The magistrate said that there had been no application to hear all the charges together and that it “reflects rather poorly on the prosecution and defence” that both parties had tried to proceed without such an order.

Hoare said that there had been an application for a joint trial in May but Pinder said there was no record of it.

The case of Lee Coaldrake, a former medical practitioner and wife of the former Queensland University of Technology vice-chancellor Peter Coaldrake, was the only case that Pinder was prepared to hear – she proceeded to plead not guilty to one charge of disrupting the legislature.

The other 13 defendants, who range in age from 24 to 88, were scheduled to have their cases mentioned on 13 November and all defendants had their bail continued.

But the confusion of the morning was amplified by the fact that those in the gallery – including the 14 accused – could not hear much of what was said. The ambiguity left one of the accused, 24-year-old Moorooka woman Aisling Geraghty, to describe the result as “disappointing”.

Story was adapted from the Guardian.

Climate changeCourtProtestersValidity
0 comment 0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
admineconai

previous post
Packham launches wildlife series on YouTube
next post
UK ‘adds’ £450m to its climate-finance spending by changing definition

Related Posts

German court dismisses climate case against RWE

May 28, 2025

WHO Climate Change action plan approved

May 28, 2025

Report: World likely to breach 1.5°C limit in...

May 28, 2025

At Bonn climate talks, Brazil demands early deals...

May 23, 2025

Guterres raises alarm over rapid Himalayan glacier melt

May 17, 2025

Study shows two-thirds of global warming caused by...

May 8, 2025

Weather expert warns climate change to hit agriculture...

May 5, 2025

Trump dismisses authors of major climate report

April 30, 2025

New UN report shows Indigenous Peoples sidelined in...

April 25, 2025

UN Report shows Climate crisis driving surge in...

April 24, 2025

Leave a Comment Cancel Reply

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Newsletter

Subscribe my Newsletter for new blog posts, tips & new photos. Let's stay updated!

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Linkedin
  • Bloglovin
  • Vimeo

@2021 - All Right Reserved. Designed and Developed by Eco-Nai+

EcoNai Newsroom
  • Newsround
  • Nigeria
  • Africa
  • World